MomUp Insights
The true cost of hiring an employee is not the recruiting fee. It is the second job that quietly gets created every time a role opens at a small company: recruiter. And it almost always lands on someone who already has a full-time job.
The posting goes up. The applications arrive, and there are more of them than ever: the average job posting drew 257.6 applications in 2025, up from 207.2 the year before, according to Employ's Hiring Benchmarks report. The person responsible for reviewing that pile is usually a founder, a department head, or the team's busiest manager, because they are the only ones who know what the role really requires.
Nobody budgets for this job. That is what makes it expensive.
What hiring actually costs in 2026
Start with the benchmark: the 2025 SHRM Benchmarking Report puts the average cost per hire at $5,475 for non-executive roles, and that figure counts direct recruiting spend only. It excludes the biggest line item at a small company, which is leadership time.
Count those hours honestly. At 250-plus applications, even a three-minute first pass is more than a full workday before a single phone screen. Then come the screens, the scheduling back-and-forth, the interviews with candidates who looked right on paper and were not. Price that time at what the leader's hours are actually worth to the business: the client work, the sales conversations, the decisions only they can make. For most small companies, the real cost of self-managed screening dwarfs the SHRM number before anyone has been interviewed twice.
The hidden costs: speed and judgment
The hours are the visible cost. Two others compound quietly.
Speed. Small and mid-sized companies averaged 83.5 days from posting to accepted offer in 2025, per Employ's data, versus 51.7 for enterprises with dedicated recruiting teams. Strong candidates do not wait three months. They are in multiple processes at once, and offer reneging has become common enough that 35% of candidates backed out even after accepting offers in early 2025. When screening happens in stolen half-hours between real work, the pool you eventually choose from is not the pool that applied.
Judgment. Screening resumes at 9pm after a full day is exactly when plausible-looking experience beats actual evidence of ability. Tired screening favors familiar titles and safe-seeming backgrounds, which is how companies end up interviewing six similar people and still feeling unsure.
What taking screening off your plate actually buys
When David Taylor Digital, a lean marketing agency, needed a Digital Marketing Account Manager, the screening would have fallen on Stella Cassidy, the Head of Customer Success, meaning the person responsible for keeping every client happy. Instead, MomUp took the screening process off her plate. Every candidate who reached her had already been evaluated for skills, working style, and values.
It was such a relief to save the time I used to spend weeding through resumes and applications and just be able to trust that qualified, pre-vetted candidates would be presented to me.
The result was a fast, confident decision and a hire, Sarah March, made quickly enough to matter. The full case study is here.
The point is not that screening is beneath a leader. It is that screening done well is a discipline: defined criteria, consistent evaluation, protected time. A recruiting partner brings all three, plus a pool of candidates who never appear on job boards at all.
How to reduce the cost of hiring if you keep it in-house
- Define the observable qualities that predict success in the role before you read a single resume, so you are screening against criteria instead of vibes.
- Batch the work into protected blocks instead of squeezing it between meetings. Judgment is better in daylight.
- Set a decision clock. Every week a process stretches, the strongest candidates fall out of it.
An open role always costs something. The question is whether you pay in leadership hours and lost candidates, or pay deliberately for a process built to protect both.
Add up what your last search cost in leadership time. If the number stings, let's talk about taking the next one off your plate.
